The mitochondrial citrate synthase (mCS) purified from the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila has been reported to form intermediate-filament-like structures during conjugation and to self-assemble into fibers when recombinantly expressed. This would represent a rare example of a tractable and recent origin of a novel cytoskeletal element. In an attempt to investigate the evolutionary emergence of this behavior, we re-investigated the ability of Tetrahymena's mCS to form filaments in vivo. Using strep-tagged mCS in Tetrahymena and monoclonal antibodies, we found no evidence of filamentous structures during conjugation or starvation. Extensive biochemical characterization of mCS revealed that the self-assembly of recombinant protein is triggered by a specific chemical moiety shared by MES and HEPES buffers used in previous studies. The absence of indicative phenotypes in fiber-deficient GFP-tagged mutants indicates that Tetrahymena mCS did not evolve a structural role in sexual reproduction or metabolic regulation.